Notes · CSAT
Reading a passage: the main idea and what is actually said
By the end, you will be able to read a short passage for its structure, state its main idea in one sentence, and tell an option that the passage supports from one that only sounds right.
What comprehension questions ask
Comprehension is the first item in the Paper II syllabus, and passages take up a large part of the paper. Most passages are short, a paragraph or two, on subjects such as the economy, the environment, society, science and governance. No knowledge of the subject is needed. Every answer is in the passage.
That last sentence is the whole method. The questions do not ask what is true. They ask what this author says, or what follows from what this author says. A statement can be perfectly true in the world and still be the wrong answer, because the passage does not say it. A candidate who has read widely is at some risk here, since familiar ideas feel correct.
The questions come in a few forms. Some ask for the main idea, the crux, the central theme or the best title. Some ask what the passage states. Some ask what can be inferred, or which assumption has been made. Some give two or three numbered statements and ask which of them are correct in the light of the passage.
This note covers the first two forms, the main idea and what is stated, which together are the base for the rest. The next note covers inference, assumption and tone.
Read for structure, not for detail
A short passage usually does one of a few things. It makes a claim and gives reasons. It describes a problem and points to a remedy. It sets out a common view and then corrects it. It weighs two aims against each other. Seeing which of these the passage is doing tells you where its weight lies.
As you read, give each sentence a job. One sentence is the claim. Others are reasons, examples or qualifications. An example is there to support something; it is rarely the point itself.
Pay special attention to turning words: but, yet, however, although, therefore, so. A sentence that begins with yet or but often carries the author's own view, after an opening that only set the scene. A sentence that begins with therefore or so states what the author draws from the reasons.
The last sentence matters. Authors of short passages often end on the point they most want to leave with the reader.
Read the passage once, steadily, without stopping to memorise details. You can look back for a detail when a question asks for it. What you cannot get by looking back is the shape of the argument, so that is what the first reading is for. A good test at the end of the reading is whether you can say in one plain sentence what the author wants you to accept.
The main idea: a test of scope
The main idea is the one statement that the whole passage is there to support. A good statement of it covers the passage from its first sentence to its last, and claims nothing more than the passage does.
Wrong options fail in four typical ways.
Too narrow. The option is true according to the passage, but it is only one of the reasons or examples. In a passage on trees and city heat, trees cool the air through evaporation is said, but it is a supporting detail.
Too broad. The option speaks of a larger subject than the passage does. Cities must change how they are built goes far beyond a passage about planting and protecting trees.
Too strong. The option turns a measured statement into an absolute one. If the passage says counting saplings says little, an option saying that counting saplings is useless and should stop has gone further than the author.
Off the point. The option brings in something the passage does not discuss, however reasonable it sounds.
So test each option twice. Does the passage say this, at this strength? And does this cover the whole passage or only a part? The right option passes both tests. Where two options seem close, the one with the more careful wording, such as may, often or some, is usually nearer to what a careful author wrote.
What the passage states
Some questions begin with according to the passage or with reference to the passage. They ask for something the author has said, though usually in other words.
Find the sentence. Do not answer from memory of the passage. Go back, find the line that the option is based on, and compare the two. The right option says the same thing in different words. A wrong option often uses the passage's own words but changes the relation between them: it swaps cause and effect, turns some into all, or attaches a reason to the wrong fact.
When the question gives numbered statements, judge each one separately and mark it true or false in the margin before looking at the answer choices. This prevents the choices from steering you.
Be careful with questions that ask what is not stated or not supported. Mark each option as supported or not, and then pick the odd one. Under time pressure it is easy to forget the not and choose the first supported option.
Finally, keep stated and implied apart. If the question says according to the passage, prefer the option that is closest to the words on the page. A reasonable further step belongs to inference questions, not to these.
Time and order
Read the passage before the questions when it is short. For a long passage with several questions, glance at the question stems first, not the options, so that you know what to look for.
Spend most of the time on the reading and on comparing the last two options. The first two wrong options usually fall quickly on scope or strength.
If two options still seem right, go back to the passage, not to your own judgement. One of them will contain a word that the passage does not support.
Practise by writing the main idea of a passage in your own sentence before looking at the options. If your sentence matches an option, you can mark it with some confidence. If nothing matches, read the passage again; do not bend your sentence towards the nearest option.
Key facts
- Every answer is in the passage; outside knowledge is set aside.
- Give each sentence a job: claim, reason, example or qualification.
- Turning words such as but, yet and therefore mark where the author's own point lies.
- Wrong main-idea options are too narrow, too broad, too strong or off the point.
- For what is stated, go back and find the sentence; do not answer from memory.
- Judge numbered statements one by one before looking at the answer choices.
- An example supports the point; it is rarely the point.
How the exam uses it
Passages are a large share of Paper II and need no formulas, so steady accuracy here goes a long way towards the qualifying mark. Marks are lost in two ways: answering from general knowledge, and choosing an option that is true but narrower or stronger than the passage. Read once for shape, and settle close calls by going back to the text.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- Why can a true statement be the wrong answer to a comprehension question?
- Name the four ways in which a main-idea option can be wrong.
- What do words such as yet and therefore tell you about a sentence?
- How should you handle a question with three numbered statements?
- Two options both seem right. What do you do next?
Sources: UPSC Civil Services Examination notification: syllabus of Preliminary Examination Paper II (comprehension); The five passages were written for this note and are not taken from any book, paper or examination
Syllabus topic: Comprehension (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Arrangements, blood relations, directions and codingCSAT
- Decision making: reading the situation and choosing a course of actionCSAT
- Inference, assumptions and toneCSAT
- Interpersonal skills: listening and respondingCSAT
- Numbers, percentages and ratios: methods that save timeCSAT
- Setting priorities and solving problems step by stepCSAT