Notes · GS4: Ethics
Case studies: setting out and weighing the options
By the end, you will be able to set out real options in a case, including ones that combine steps, and weigh each against law, consequences, duties and character.
18
PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 18
Why options are asked for
Many case studies ask the candidate to state the options available and to evaluate each. Even where the question asks only what will you do, a good answer shows that other courses were considered and says why they were set aside.
The purpose is to test range and fairness of mind. A person who sees only one course has not thought; a person who sees two, one saintly and one corrupt, has thought very little. Real situations offer several workable courses, each with something to be said for it.
An option, to count, has to be something a person in the given role could actually do. Resign in protest, obey silently, and report everything to the media are options in the sense that they are possible, but an answer built only from such extremes has not engaged with the case.
Generating options
Begin with the plain courses the case itself suggests. Usually there are three: go along with what is being asked, refuse it outright, or pass the matter to someone else. Write them down. They are the base line.
Then look for the middle ground, which is where the best answers are usually found. Four questions help.
Can the facts be established first? An inquiry, an inspection, a second opinion or a look at the records is itself an option, and often the first step of any sound course.
Can the harm be prevented now while the larger question is settled properly? A building can be vacated while its safety is tested. A payment can be held while a complaint is checked.
Can the legitimate need behind an improper request be met in a proper way? A person who asks for a rule to be bent usually has a real need. There may be a scheme, an exemption provided in the rules, or a different office that can meet it.
Can the steps be put in sequence? Speak to the person first; if that fails, report to the senior; if that fails, go to the authority provided by law. A sequence of this kind is one option, and it is usually stronger than any single step.
Three or four well-described options are enough. Each should be stated as an action with a verb, such as order a structural audit and shift classes to the panchayat hall meanwhile, and not as an attitude, such as be firm.
Four tests for weighing
Weigh each option on the same set of tests, so that the comparison is fair.
Law and rules. Is the option lawful, and is it within the authority of the role? This test comes first because an unlawful option cannot be rescued by good results. The Constitution, the statute concerned and the conduct rules of the service are the usual reference points; name one only if you are sure it applies.
Consequences. Who gains and who loses, how much, and how soon? Consider the long term and the precedent as well as the immediate result. An option that relieves one family today and teaches a whole district that rules can be set aside for those who press hard has a cost that does not show at once.
Duties and rights. Does the option keep faith with what is owed to each person: a hearing to the accused, safety to the public, truth to the senior, equal treatment to citizens? Some things may not be done to a person even for a good result. Using someone merely as a means, or punishing without a hearing, fails this test whatever it achieves.
Character. What would a person of integrity, courage and compassion do here, and what does the option make of the one who chooses it? A useful form of this test is publicity: would I be willing to explain this decision, with my reasons, to those affected and to the public?
The four tests correspond to the main ways of moral reasoning in the syllabus on thinkers: reasoning from results, from duty and from virtue, with law as the frame within which a public servant works. A case answer need not name the schools. It should show that more than one kind of reason has been considered.
When the tests agree, the choice is easy. When they pull apart, say so. That is the dilemma, and naming it accurately is worth more than hiding it.
Being fair to every option
For each option give merits and demerits honestly. An option you will reject still has something for it, or no reasonable person would be tempted. Obeying the senior keeps the hierarchy working and protects your career; say so, and then say what it costs. An option you will choose still has a cost; say that too.
Keep the evaluation tied to the case. Not this option may cause public anger, but residents of the colony, who have waited two years for the road, are likely to protest if work stops again.
Avoid two faults. One is the straw option, set up only to be knocked down, such as accept the bribe. If the case is a plain test of integrity, say that the improper course is not an option for a public servant and spend the space on how to do the right thing well. The other is the costless option, described as if it had no demerit. Every real course has one.
A compact way to present the weighing is a table with the options in rows and columns for merits, demerits and a one-line verdict. Where time is short, two lines of merit and two of demerit under each option do the same work.
An illustration
Suppose the case is this. You are the head of a district education office. An inspection finds that a government school building, in use by three hundred children, has deep cracks. The examinations begin in ten days. The contractor who built it is said to be well connected.
The options might be set out as follows. One, let the school run until the examinations are over and then repair. Its merit is no disruption; its demerit is a risk to life, which no gain can balance. Two, close the school at once until further orders. It removes the risk and leaves three hundred children without a place for their examinations. Three, shift classes and the examination to a nearby safe public building from tomorrow, order a structural test of the school by the competent engineer, and report to the Collector with a request for an inquiry into the construction. It removes the risk, protects the examinations, and starts accountability on the basis of a technical finding and not of rumour. Its cost is effort and some inconvenience.
The third option is a combined and sequenced one, built by asking the four questions above. The next note takes up how to choose and defend such a course.
Key facts
- An option must be something a person in the given role could actually do.
- Start with the plain courses, then look for the middle ground.
- Four questions build better options: establish facts, prevent harm now, meet the real need properly, put steps in sequence.
- Weigh every option on the same four tests: law, consequences, duties and rights, character.
- An unlawful option cannot be rescued by good results.
- Give honest merits and demerits for every option, including the one you will choose.
- State each option as an action, not as an attitude.
How the exam uses it
Where a case asks for options, the marks go to range, realism and honest weighing. Three or four options, one of them a combined and sequenced course, each with merits and demerits tied to the facts of the case, is a sound pattern. Lists of values without action, straw options and costless options are the usual reasons an answer reads as mechanical.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- What makes something a real option in a case answer?
- Which four questions help to find the middle ground?
- State the four tests for weighing an option.
- What are a straw option and a costless option?
- Why does the test of law come first for a public servant?
Sources: UPSC Civil Services Examination notification: syllabus of General Studies Paper IV, 'Case Studies on above issues'; The illustration was written for this note and is not taken from any examination
Syllabus topic: Case studies (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Moral and political attitudes; social influence and persuasionGS4: Ethics
- Aptitude and the foundational values of civil serviceGS4: Ethics
- Moral thinkers from India: core ideas and where they fitGS4: Ethics
- Case studies: reading the case and the people involvedGS4: Ethics
- Self-mastery and the duty of those who govern: the Dhammapada, Kautilya, Confucius and TagoreGS4: Ethics
- Ethics and the human interface: essence, determinants, consequencesGS4: Ethics