Quick question 1
What made Sameer's file hard for Ravi?
The papers looked fine; the problem was the friendship, which no one else knew about.
Case files · 1:53
Sound is off until you turn it on. Captions are on.
Quick question 1
The papers looked fine; the problem was the friendship, which no one else knew about.
Quick question 2
Declaring and stepping aside protects both the public interest and the applicant's right to a fair decision.
A made up case. Ravi is a land officer in a busy town. His stack of files has, by all accounts, never once got shorter. Today, one file stops him. The applicant is Sameer, his college room mate. They once shared one blanket, and two exams' worth of panic. Sameer wants a no objection certificate for a shop on family land. The papers look fine. No one in the office knows they are friends. The dilemma: can Ravi judge a friend's file fairly, and be seen to? Option A: clear it quickly. Option B: reject it, to stay above suspicion. Option C: declare the friendship in writing, and ask for another officer. Pause here, and choose. Option A trusts a friendship, not the file. The rules ask for merit alone. Option B looks strict, but punishes Sameer for knowing Ravi. That is not fair either. Option C follows the Conduct Rules: declare a private interest, and resolve the conflict in the public interest. A sound answer names the conflict, writes it down, steps aside, and lets merit decide. For GS4: a friendship is not a crime. Hiding it is the problem. Ravi sends a short note to his senior. Then he calls Sameer, and they talk about everything, except the file.
18
PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 18