Quick question 1
What did Tara notice about one name on the relief list?
The family had no recorded damage, yet the name was on a list meant for people who lost homes.
Case files · 1:45
Sound is off until you turn it on. Captions are on.
Quick question 1
The family had no recorded damage, yet the name was on a list meant for people who lost homes.
Quick question 2
Rule 3(1)(xvi) asks officers to make choices, take decisions and make recommendations on merit alone.
A made up case. Tara is a District Collector. After the floods, a relief list reaches her desk: families whose homes were damaged. She reads it twice. One name is missing from the damage survey: Dhanraj, a man of means. Somehow, the list has made room for his means. The phone calls have begun. Everyone says the same thing: let it pass. The dilemma: whose name stays on the list, and who decides? Option A: let it pass, and keep the peace. Option B: strike the name quietly, and say nothing. Option C: check the survey, record the reason, and inform her senior. Pause here, and choose. Option A shares relief by influence. The Conduct Rules say: decide on merit alone. Option B is right in result, but leaves no record. Public decisions should be open, and answerable. Option C checks the facts, writes the reason, tells the senior, and shows the final list. A sound answer checks the survey, records the reason, informs the senior, and puts the list in public view. For GS4: relief by loss, not by name. Decide on merit, and keep the record open. By evening the list is pinned outside the office. The queue is long, but everyone in it has lost something.
18
PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 18