Notes · GS2: Polity, Governance, IR
Panchayati Raj: the 73rd Amendment and after
By the end, you will know how panchayats got constitutional status, how the three tiers, Gram Sabha, SFC and SEC work, what PESA adds, and what is debated.
The road to the 73rd Amendment
Article 40, a Directive Principle, asks the State to organise village panchayats and give them the powers they need to work as units of self-government. For decades, though, panchayats depended entirely on state laws.
The Balwant Rai Mehta Committee of 1957, set up to review the Community Development Programme, recommended 'democratic decentralisation' through a three-tier system. Rajasthan was the first state to adopt it, at Nagaur on 2 October 1959. Many states followed, but the system weakened over time: elections were postponed, and bodies were often superseded.
Later committees looked at the problem again. The Ashok Mehta Committee of 1977 to 1978 suggested a two-tier system. The L. M. Singhvi Committee of 1986 recommended that panchayats be given constitutional recognition and protection.
The 64th Amendment Bill of 1989, which sought to do this, passed the Lok Sabha but was defeated in the Rajya Sabha. Parliament finally passed the Constitution (73rd Amendment) Act in 1992. It came into force on 24 April 1993, a date now marked as National Panchayati Raj Day.
The Amendment added Part IX, 'The Panchayats', covering Articles 243 to 243-O, and the Eleventh Schedule, which lists 29 subjects.
Structure: tiers, seats and terms
Article 243B provides for panchayats at the village, intermediate and district levels. A state with a population not exceeding 20 lakh need not set up the intermediate level.
All seats are filled by direct election from territorial constituencies. The chairpersons of the intermediate and district panchayats are elected indirectly, by and from the elected members. How the village chairperson is elected is left to the state law.
Article 243D deals with reservation. Seats are reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in proportion to their population. Not less than one-third of the total seats, including those reserved for SCs and STs, are reserved for women. Offices of chairpersons are also reserved for SCs, STs and women on the same principles. States may make reservation for backward classes.
Under Article 243E, every panchayat has a five-year term from its first meeting. If it is dissolved earlier, a fresh election must be completed within six months.
A person must be 21 years old to be a member. Other disqualifications follow the law applicable to elections to the state legislature, along with any laid down by the state's panchayat law.
Gram Sabha, SFC and SEC
Three institutions give the system its shape.
The Gram Sabha, under Article 243A, is a body of all persons registered in the electoral rolls of a village within the area of a panchayat. It is direct democracy at the local level. The Constitution leaves its powers and functions to the state legislature. In practice, it approves plans, identifies beneficiaries of schemes and can hold the panchayat to account through social audits.
The State Finance Commission, under Article 243I, is set up by the Governor within one year of the Amendment and then every five years. It reviews panchayat finances and recommends how taxes, duties, tolls and fees should be shared between the state and panchayats, and what grants-in-aid they should receive.
The State Election Commission, under Article 243K, conducts panchayat elections. The State Election Commissioner is appointed by the Governor and can be removed only in the manner and on the grounds of a High Court judge. This protects the office from pressure.
The Union Finance Commission is linked too. Under Article 280(3)(bb), it recommends measures to augment a state's Consolidated Fund to supplement panchayat resources, based on the SFC's recommendations.
Powers and the 'three Fs'
Article 243G says the state legislature may endow panchayats with powers and authority to function as institutions of self-government. This includes preparing plans and implementing schemes for economic development and social justice, including those on the 29 subjects in the Eleventh Schedule. These range from agriculture and drinking water to primary education, health and women and child development.
The key word is 'may'. Devolution is left to each state. As a result, the real powers of panchayats differ widely across India.
Article 243H allows the state legislature to authorise panchayats to levy, collect and keep certain taxes, duties, tolls and fees, and to give them grants-in-aid.
Discussion of devolution often uses the idea of the 'three Fs': functions, funds and functionaries. A panchayat needs all three. It must be given clear functions, the money to carry them out, and the staff to do the work. If any one is missing, the other two lose much of their value.
Article 243-O bars courts from interfering in panchayat electoral matters, such as delimitation of constituencies and allotment of seats. An election can be questioned only through an election petition.
PESA: self-rule in Scheduled Areas
Article 243M says Part IX does not apply on its own to certain areas: Nagaland, Meghalaya and Mizoram, the hill areas of Manipur with district councils, the Darjeeling hill areas, and the Scheduled and tribal areas. Parliament may extend it to Scheduled Areas with changes.
It did so through the Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996, known as PESA, following the Bhuria Committee's recommendations. PESA covers Fifth Schedule areas, which lie in ten states.
PESA places the Gram Sabha at the centre. State laws on panchayats in these areas must be consistent with customary law, social and religious practices, and traditional management of community resources.
The Gram Sabha or the appropriate panchayat is given specific powers. It must be consulted before land acquisition for development projects and before resettlement. It is to have ownership of minor forest produce. It has powers to prevent land alienation and restore unlawfully alienated land, to manage village markets, to control money lending to Scheduled Tribes, and to regulate the sale of intoxicants.
At least half the seats in each panchayat in these areas are reserved for Scheduled Tribes, and all chairperson posts are reserved for them.
How it works, and what is debated
The 73rd Amendment brought regular elections and a large number of elected representatives into local government, many of them women and members of SCs and STs. Several states have raised reservation for women in panchayats to half the seats.
The weak points are well known. Many states have devolved functions on paper without the funds or staff to match. Panchayats raise little revenue of their own and depend on grants tied to particular schemes. SFC reports have often been delayed, and their recommendations not fully acted upon. Parallel bodies and departmental committees sometimes bypass elected panchayats.
A second concern is proxy representation, where a male relative exercises the powers of an elected woman. Some argue this is fading as women gain experience and training; others see it as persistent and hard to address.
PESA's implementation has also been uneven. Several states were slow to frame rules, and the powers of the Gram Sabha over land and forest produce often remain limited in practice.
State laws that set eligibility conditions, such as educational qualifications or limits on the number of children, have been debated. Supporters cite good governance; critics cite exclusion.
Key facts
- Article 40 directs the State to organise village panchayats.
- Rajasthan first adopted Panchayati Raj at Nagaur on 2 October 1959.
- The 73rd Amendment came into force on 24 April 1993.
- Part IX covers Articles 243 to 243-O; the Eleventh Schedule lists 29 subjects.
- States with population not exceeding 20 lakh need not have the intermediate tier.
- Not less than one-third of panchayat seats are reserved for women.
- Article 243I provides for the SFC; Article 243K for the SEC.
- PESA, 1996 extends Part IX to Fifth Schedule areas, centred on the Gram Sabha.
How the exam uses it
Prelims asks statement questions on articles, the minimum age, the 20 lakh rule, reservation, the SFC, the SEC and PESA powers. Mains asks you to assess fiscal devolution, the role of the Gram Sabha, women's representation, or why PESA's implementation has lagged.
Both sides
Some argue the 73rd Amendment created a strong framework and that the gaps lie in state-level political will to devolve funds, functions and functionaries. Others argue the framework itself is too weak, since devolution is optional under Article 243G. Views also differ on eligibility conditions and on how much proxy representation persists.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- Which committee first recommended a three-tier system, and where was it first adopted?
- How are the chairpersons of the intermediate and district panchayats elected?
- What does Article 280(3)(bb) ask the Union Finance Commission to do for panchayats?
- Why does the word 'may' in Article 243G matter for the powers of panchayats?
- Name three powers that PESA gives the Gram Sabha or panchayat in Scheduled Areas.
Sources: Constitution of India, Part IX; Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996
More notes
- Transparency and accountability: RTI, citizen charters, social auditGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- e-Governance: models, applications, limits and user-centred designGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Civil services in a democracy: neutrality, accountability, reformGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Development actors: NGOs, SHGs, pressure groups, civil society, donorsGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Welfare of vulnerable sections: laws, institutions, mechanismsGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Issues relating to health: system tiers, financing, key programmesGS2: Polity, Governance, IR