Quick question 1
Why did Arun say Article 44 cannot simply be enforced?
Directive Principles are not enforceable by any court (Article 37).
Both sides, and myth or fact · 1:49
Sound is off until you turn it on. Captions are on.
Quick question 1
Directive Principles are not enforceable by any court (Article 37).
Quick question 2
It proposed amending and codifying personal laws to remove discrimination; difference is not always discrimination.
Next morning, same tea stall. Meher and Arun, our made up friends, take up Article 44. One law for all on marriage, divorce, inheritance and adoption? The Constitution asks for it. Article 44: the State shall endeavour to secure a uniform civil code. It's a Directive Principle, so no court can enforce it. And Article 25 protects the freedom to practise religion. It's about equal rights. Today a woman's rights in marriage or inheritance can depend on her religion. One code treats all alike. Then fix the unfair rules. In 2018, the Law Commission said: reform within each personal law. Difference is not always discrimination. And it can work. Goa has long followed one civil code. In 1985, the Supreme Court said it would help national integration. But customs differ. Even Uttarakhand's and Gujarat's new codes leave out Scheduled Tribes, whose customs the Constitution itself protects. What the record says. Article 44 is a directive. In 2018, the Law Commission called a uniform code neither necessary nor desirable then. Uttarakhand passed one in 2024, Gujarat in 2026. For GS2 and GS1: both sides, fairly. Then a balanced way forward. Their order was the one uniform thing: two glasses, same tea. The question stays on the table.
22
PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 22