Q58 2 marks
Consider the following subjects under the Constitution of India
I. List I-Union List, in the Seventh Schedule
II. Extent of the executive power of a State
III. Conditions of the Governor’s office For a constitutional amendment with respect to which of the above, ratification by the Legislatures of not less than one-half of the States is required before presenting the bill to the President of India for assent?
UPSC's answer: (a) I and II only
The proviso to Article 368(2) lists what needs ratification by at least half the State Legislatures. It includes 'any of the Lists in the Seventh Schedule', which covers the Union List, and Article 162, which sets the extent of a State's executive power. Article 158 (conditions of the Governor's office) is not on the list. So I and II only.
- (b) Includes III, which is not in the proviso, and leaves out I.
- (c) Includes III and leaves out II (Article 162).
- (d) III does not need State ratification.
The trap: Assuming anything about the Governor touches federalism and so needs State ratification. Only the items named in the proviso do.