Notes · GS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
Security forces and agencies, their mandates, and AFSPA
By the end, you will know who does what in India's security system, what the Constitution says about the Union's duty to the states, and both sides of the AFSPA debate.
45
PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 45
The constitutional frame
Start with who is responsible. Under the Seventh Schedule, public order and police are State List subjects, so state governments and their police are the first line for internal security. Defence of India and the armed forces are Union List subjects.
The Union also has a duty. Article 355 says it shall be the duty of the Union to protect every state against external aggression and internal disturbance, and to ensure that every state's government is carried on in accordance with the Constitution.
In practice, this lets the Union deploy its forces to help a state. In an extreme case, Article 352 allows a national emergency on the ground of war, external aggression or armed rebellion. The words 'armed rebellion' replaced 'internal disturbance' through the 44th Amendment of 1978, to make misuse harder.
So the system is layered: state police first, central forces in aid, and the armed forces as a last resort for internal tasks. Can you say which article sets the Union's duty?
Who does what: forces and agencies
The armed forces, the Army, Navy and Air Force, are under the Ministry of Defence. Their main task is defence against external threats; they help civil authorities in internal security when called.
The Central Armed Police Forces are under the Ministry of Home Affairs. They include the Central Reserve Police Force, the main force for helping states with law and order and counter-insurgency; the Border Security Force, the Indo-Tibetan Border Police and the Sashastra Seema Bal, which guard frontiers; the Central Industrial Security Force, which protects airports, ports and key industries; and the Assam Rifles. The National Security Guard is a specialised counter-terror force.
Intelligence is split between two main bodies. The Intelligence Bureau handles internal intelligence. The Research and Analysis Wing, set up in 1968, handles external intelligence.
Coordination is the recurring challenge. Answers often mention the need for real-time sharing between central and state agencies, and the role of the National Security Council structure, headed by the National Security Adviser.
A recent example of the division of labour: in the campaign against Left Wing Extremism that the government says ended by 31 March 2026, state police led operations while central armed police forces supported them and the Union funded fortified police stations and roads.
AFSPA: what the law provides
The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958, AFSPA, applies only in areas declared 'disturbed'. A declaration can be made by the Union government or by the Governor of the state, and it can be reviewed and withdrawn. Similar Acts have applied to Punjab and to Jammu and Kashmir at different times.
In a disturbed area, the Act gives the armed forces powers that ordinary law does not. An authorised officer may, after due warning, use force, even to the point of causing death, against a person breaking laws or orders on assemblies or weapons. Officers may arrest without a warrant and search premises without a warrant. No prosecution can be started against a member of the forces for acts under the Act without the sanction of the Union government.
In Naga People's Movement of Human Rights v. Union of India (1997), the Supreme Court upheld the Act's constitutionality, while setting out safeguards, such as handing arrested persons quickly to the nearest police station, and periodic review of declarations.
AFSPA: the debate on both sides
The case for AFSPA, as its supporters make it: soldiers in insurgency face armed opponents who blend into the population, and they need legal cover to act quickly. Without it, they argue, the forces would be reluctant to deploy, and insurgents would gain.
The case against, as its critics make it: wide powers and the need for sanction before prosecution can weaken accountability, and long use of the Act can alienate local people. Two official bodies recommended repeal. The Committee headed by Justice B. P. Jeevan Reddy, which reported in 2005, recommended repealing AFSPA and adding needed provisions to UAPA. The Second Administrative Reforms Commission, in its report on public order in 2007, also recommended repeal.
Over time, the areas declared disturbed have been reduced in several states. A balanced answer explains the security need, the human rights concern, the court's safeguards, and a way forward such as time-bound reviews, quicker inquiries and stronger state police capacity. Never write a verdict on the government; describe the positions.
Key facts
- Public order and police are in the State List; defence is in the Union List.
- Article 355 makes it the Union's duty to protect states against external aggression and internal disturbance.
- The 44th Amendment (1978) replaced 'internal disturbance' with 'armed rebellion' in Article 352.
- The CRPF is the main CAPF for aiding states in law and order and counter-insurgency.
- The IB handles internal intelligence; R&AW, set up in 1968, handles external intelligence.
- AFSPA (1958) applies only in areas declared 'disturbed'; prosecution needs Union sanction.
- The Supreme Court upheld AFSPA in Naga People's Movement of Human Rights (1997), with safeguards.
- The Jeevan Reddy Committee (2005) and the Second ARC (2007) recommended repeal of AFSPA.
How the exam uses it
Mains asks about the mandates of security forces and agencies, Centre-state coordination, and the debate over AFSPA. Prelims asks which ministry controls which force, and the meaning of Articles 352 and 355. Present AFSPA with the case for, the case against, the court's safeguards and a balanced way forward. Past papers: Prelims 2025 Q53 asked which of the Inter-State Council, the National Security Council and Zonal Councils were set up under the Constitution (UPSC key: only one, the Inter-State Council); Mains 2025 GS3 Q19 asked about internal security and peace accords in the North-East. The usual mistake is to call the NSC or CAPFs constitutional bodies; they rest on executive decisions and Acts of Parliament.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- What does Article 355 say, and how does it relate to Article 352?
- Name four Central Armed Police Forces and the main task of each.
- What powers does AFSPA give in a disturbed area, and who can declare an area disturbed?
- Give the strongest argument on each side of the AFSPA debate, with one official body that recommended repeal.
Sources: PIB backgrounder on India becoming effectively free from Naxalism on 31 March 2026, https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2292864, opened 2026-11-20
Syllabus topic: Internal security: extremism, borders, cyber, money laundering (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Measuring growth: GDP, GVA and national incomeGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Inflation and monetary policy: how India measures prices and how the RBI targets themGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Banking in India: structure, bad loans and inclusionGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Government budgeting and taxation: the Budget, deficits, FRBM and GSTGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Agriculture: MSP, procurement, the PDS and farm supportGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Industry, liberalisation and infrastructure since 1991GS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security