Notes · GS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
Investment models for infrastructure: EPC, PPP, the hybrid annuity, InvITs and asset monetisation
By the end, you will be able to say who bears which risk under each model, explain why the hybrid annuity model was introduced, and describe how India recycles finished assets to fund new ones.
18
PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 18
The question every model answers
The syllabus names investment models for infrastructure. Every model answers the same question: who pays for the asset, who bears each risk, and who collects the revenue. The main risks in a project are construction risk, that it costs more or takes longer than planned; traffic or demand risk, that fewer people use it than expected; financing risk, that interest rates rise; and land and approval risk, that the site or permits are delayed. A model works when each risk sits with the party best able to manage it. Most failures of Indian infrastructure finance in the early 2010s came from putting a risk on the wrong party.
A rough rule helps. Construction risk is best borne by the builder, who controls the work. Land and approval risk is best borne by the government, which alone can acquire land and grant permits. Traffic risk depends on the project: on a busy, established route a private operator can price it, but on a new road in a slow-growing region nobody can forecast it well, so it often sits better with the government. Keep this rule in mind while reading each model below.
Public delivery: EPC
Under engineering, procurement and construction, the government designs the project, pays for it in full from its budget and hires a contractor to build it for a fixed price. The contractor bears construction risk up to handover; the government owns the asset and bears all other risks, including traffic. It collects any tolls itself. EPC is simple and avoids disputes over revenue sharing, but it puts the whole cost on the public budget, and since the contractor's job ends at completion it has little reason to build for low maintenance cost over the asset's life. Most national highway building in recent years has been through EPC, financed by the large rise in public capital expenditure.
Public-private partnership: BOT and its troubles
Under build, operate and transfer, a private concessionaire raises the money, builds the asset, operates it for a concession period of often twenty to thirty years, collects user charges such as tolls to recover its investment, and hands the asset back at the end. In the toll version the private party bears traffic risk. In the annuity version the government pays it a fixed sum every six months instead, and keeps the traffic risk. Variants include build, own, operate and transfer, where the private party also owns the asset during the concession. Where a project is useful but cannot earn enough to attract a bidder, the Union's viability gap funding scheme of 2006 can pay up to twenty per cent of the project cost, with the sponsoring authority able to add a further twenty. Since its revamp in November 2020, social infrastructure projects such as water, health and education can get up to thirty per cent from the Union and thirty more from the sponsor.
India had a boom in toll road partnerships in the late 2000s. Many bidders, competing aggressively, overestimated traffic; then land acquisition and environmental approvals were delayed, costs rose and growth slowed. Projects stalled, developers could not repay, and their loans became a large part of the bad debts of public sector banks. A committee chaired by Vijay Kelkar, which reported in 2015, recommended better risk sharing, a mechanism to renegotiate failing contracts, and an independent regulator.
The hybrid annuity model and toll-operate-transfer
The hybrid annuity model, adopted for highways in 2016, was designed to bring private builders back without loading them with risks they could not bear. The government pays forty per cent of the project cost during construction, in instalments linked to progress. The private developer finances the other sixty per cent and is repaid with interest through annuities over about fifteen years after completion, along with payments for operation and maintenance. The government collects the tolls and keeps the traffic risk; the developer keeps construction and maintenance risk. Because the developer needs to raise only part of the cost and is not exposed to traffic, banks are more willing to lend.
Toll-operate-transfer works the other way round. The government offers a road that is already built and earning tolls to a private operator for a long concession, often thirty years, in return for a large upfront payment. The operator collects tolls and maintains the road. The first bundle of national highways was awarded this way in 2018. The government gets money now to build new roads; the operator gets an asset with known traffic and no construction risk.
Recycling assets: InvITs and the monetisation pipelines
Toll-operate-transfer is one form of a wider idea, asset recycling: selling the right to the income of finished public assets to investors with long horizons, such as pension and insurance funds, and using the money to build new ones. Ownership stays with the government. Two market instruments, regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India under rules of 2014, make this easier. An infrastructure investment trust, or InvIT, pools income-earning infrastructure such as roads, power lines or pipelines and issues units to investors, who receive most of the cash flow as distributions; a real estate investment trust does the same for offices and malls. The National Highways Authority, the power transmission company and the gas pipeline company have each set up InvITs.
The National Monetisation Pipeline of August 2021 listed brownfield assets that could raise about six lakh crore rupees over 2022 to 2025, led by roads, railways and power. Against a target of about 4.3 lakh crore rupees for its first three years, about 3.86 lakh crore was achieved. Budget 2025-26 announced a second asset monetisation plan for 2025 to 2030 with a target of ten lakh crore rupees. Budget 2026-27 added an Infrastructure Risk Guarantee Fund, to give lenders partial credit guarantees during construction, and dedicated REITs to recycle real estate of public sector companies. The National Bank for Financing Infrastructure and Development, set up under an Act of 2021, adds a long-term lender to the system. Critics ask whether monetisation is priced fairly, and whether private operators will maintain assets well and keep user charges reasonable; both depend on the quality of contracts and regulation.
Key facts
- EPC: government pays all and bears traffic risk; contractor bears construction risk only.
- BOT (toll): private party finances, operates and bears traffic risk; BOT (annuity): government pays fixed annuities.
- Viability gap funding (2006): up to 20 per cent from the Union, plus up to 20 per cent from the sponsoring authority; 30 plus 30 for social infrastructure since 2020.
- Kelkar Committee (2015) on revisiting and revitalising PPPs.
- Hybrid annuity model (2016): government 40 per cent during construction; developer 60 per cent repaid by annuities; government keeps traffic risk.
- Toll-operate-transfer: upfront payment for an operating road; first bundle 2018.
- InvITs and REITs: SEBI regulations of 2014.
- National Monetisation Pipeline (August 2021): about 6 lakh crore rupees, 2022-25; second plan for 2025-30 targets 10 lakh crore.
How the exam uses it
Prelims asks who bears traffic risk under each model, the government's share under the hybrid annuity model, and what an InvIT is. Mains asks why private participation in infrastructure fell after 2012 and how the newer models respond; organise the answer around risk allocation, and end with the conditions for asset monetisation to work. Past paper: Prelims 2023 Q21 tested InvITs; UPSC's key holds that InvITs are recognised as borrowers under the SARFAESI Act, while the tax statement was wrong. The usual mistake is to say the developer bears traffic risk under the hybrid annuity model; the government does.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- List four risks in an infrastructure project.
- Who bears traffic risk under EPC, BOT-toll and the hybrid annuity model?
- Why did many toll road partnerships fail in the early 2010s?
- How does toll-operate-transfer help the government build new roads?
- What does an InvIT hold and what do its investors receive?
Sources: PIB, Cabinet approves continuation and revamping of the VGF scheme, 11 November 2020, https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1671914, opened 2026-11-21; PIB (NITI Aayog), National Monetisation Pipeline achievements, 2024, https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2026675, opened 2026-11-21; Budget 2025-26, Speech of the Minister of Finance, 1 February 2025, https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/budget2025-26/doc/Budget_Speech.pdf, opened 2026-11-20; Budget 2026-27, Speech of the Minister of Finance, 1 February 2026, https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/doc/budget_speech.pdf, opened 2026-11-20; UPSC question paper csp-2023-gs1 with official answer key https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/AnsKey-CSP-2023-Paper-I-090524.pdf, https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/QP_CS_Pre_Exam_2023_280523.pdf, opened 2026-11-03
Syllabus topic: Industry, liberalisation and infrastructure (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Measuring growth: GDP, GVA and national incomeGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Inflation and monetary policy: how India measures prices and how the RBI targets themGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Banking in India: structure, bad loans and inclusionGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Government budgeting and taxation: the Budget, deficits, FRBM and GSTGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Agriculture: MSP, procurement, the PDS and farm supportGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Industry, liberalisation and infrastructure since 1991GS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security