Aspiran

Notes · GS4: Ethics

Gandhi and Ambedkar in their own words

By the end, you will be able to state, from Hind Swaraj and from two speeches in the Constituent Assembly, what Gandhi held about means and self-rule and what Ambedkar held about constitutional morality, equality and fraternity.

10 min read Updated 2026-11-14

11

PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 11

'16'17'18'19'20'21'22'233'244'254'26

Two texts, two questions

This note reads two sets of primary texts. The first is Hind Swaraj, which M. K. Gandhi wrote on a voyage from London to South Africa as a dialogue between a Reader and an Editor, and published in English as Indian Home Rule. The second is Dr B. R. Ambedkar's speeches in the Constituent Assembly on 4 November 1948, when he introduced the Draft Constitution, and on 25 November 1949, the day before the Constitution was adopted.

The two were asking different questions. Gandhi was asking what freedom is and how it may rightly be won. Ambedkar, as Chairman of the Drafting Committee, was asking what a people must do to keep the democracy they had just made. They disagreed on important matters, and the last section notes one disagreement in Ambedkar's own words. An answer in the examination should present each thinker accurately and need not rank them.

The quotations from Hind Swaraj are from the English text. The quotations from Ambedkar are from a published transcription of the Constituent Assembly Debates; the official printed volumes were not opened for this note. The Hindi renderings are ours.

Gandhi: means and ends

In chapter XVI of Hind Swaraj the Reader argues that any means, including force, may be used to gain a good end. The Editor answers with an image: 'The means may be likened to a seed, the end to a tree; and there is just the same inviolable connection between the means and the end as there is between the seed and the tree.' A little earlier he puts it more sharply: the Reader's reasoning 'is the same as saying that we can get a rose through planting a noxious weed.'

The claim is stronger than the ordinary advice that one should use fair methods. Gandhi is saying that the means are already part of the result. A freedom won by deceit will carry deceit into its institutions. He gives the example of three ways of getting a watch: by fighting for it, by paying for it, and by pleading for it. The watch is in each case a different thing: stolen property, one's own property, or a gift.

For a public servant the application is direct. A target met by falsifying a record has not been met. An order enforced by humiliating people has purchased compliance and lost trust. When a case study offers a quick result by a doubtful method, this is the idea to bring to it, and the sentence about the seed and the tree is the one to quote.

Gandhi: self-rule, duty and soul-force

The conclusion of Hind Swaraj lists what the Editor has tried to show. The first item is: 'Real home-rule is self-rule or self-control.' Political freedom is, for Gandhi, an outward form of an inner condition. A people that cannot govern its own desires will not be free merely because its rulers have changed.

The same thought appears in his account of civilisation in chapter XIII: 'Civilization is that mode of conduct which points out to man the path of duty. Performance of duty and observance of morality are convertible terms. To observe morality is to attain mastery over our mind and our passions.' The measure of a civilisation is conduct, not comfort or machinery.

In chapter XVII he describes the method that follows from these ideas. 'Passive resistance is a method of securing rights by personal suffering; it is the reverse of resistance by arms.' And: 'If I do not obey the law and accept the penalty for its breach, I use soul-force. It involves sacrifice of self.' Two features should be noticed. The resister breaks the law openly and accepts the punishment; there is no evasion. And the cost of a mistake falls on the resister alone: 'if this kind of force is used in a cause that is unjust only the person using it suffers.'

For the Ethics paper, three ideas come from these passages. Self-control is the root of public conduct, so integrity is first a matter of governing oneself. Duty comes before rights in Gandhi's ordering. And conscience may require a person to refuse, but openly and at one's own cost. A civil servant's situation differs from a citizen's, since the servant has accepted the discipline of the service; the usual forms of conscience there are the recorded dissent and the refusal to carry out an unlawful order, not disobedience at large.

Ambedkar: constitutional morality and the people who work a constitution

Introducing the Draft Constitution on 4 November 1948, Ambedkar explained why it contained so much administrative detail. Such detail can be left out, he said, only where the people are 'saturated with Constitutional morality'. He went on: 'Constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated. We must realize that our people have yet to learn it.'

Constitutional morality here means a settled respect for the forms and limits of the Constitution, held by those in office and by citizens, even when those forms are inconvenient. It is a habit, and like any habit it is formed by practice.

A year later, on 25 November 1949, he returned to the point from another side: 'however good a Constitution may be, it is sure to turn out bad because those who are called to work it, happen to be a bad lot. However bad a Constitution may be, it may turn out to be good if those who are called to work it, happen to be a good lot.' The text can provide only the organs of the State; how they work depends on the people and on those whom the people choose.

For a civil servant these two passages are close to a statement of the purpose of the Ethics paper. Rules and institutions do not carry themselves out. An officer who follows the form of a procedure while defeating its purpose has the letter without the morality.

Ambedkar: three cautions, and social democracy

In the speech of 25 November 1949 Ambedkar named three things to be done if democracy was to be kept in fact as well as in form.

The first: 'hold fast to constitutional methods of achieving our social and economic objectives.' Where constitutional methods are open, he said, there can be no justification for unconstitutional ones, and he included civil disobedience, non-cooperation and satyagraha among the methods to be abandoned, calling them 'the Grammar of Anarchy'. This is the point at which he differs from Gandhi's method, and it should be reported as his view, with his condition: that constitutional methods are open.

The second: not to lay liberties at the feet of any great man. 'Bhakti in religion may be a road to the salvation of the soul. But in politics, Bhakti or hero-worship is a sure road to degradation and to eventual dictatorship.'

The third: 'not to be content with mere political democracy. We must make our political democracy a social democracy as well.' Social democracy 'means a way of life which recognizes liberty, equality and fraternity as the principles of life', and the three cannot be separated: 'Without equality, liberty would produce the supremacy of the few over the many. Equality without liberty would kill individual initiative.' Without fraternity, he added, liberty and equality 'would require a constable to enforce them.'

He then described the position on the day the Constitution would come into force: 'On the 26th of January 1950, we are going to enter into a life of contradictions. In politics we will have equality and in social and economic life we will have inequality.'

For the examination, these passages support answers on impartiality, on compassion towards the weaker sections, on the dangers of personal loyalty in public life, and on why equality before the law is not the whole of equality.

Key facts

  • Gandhi, Hind Swaraj: 'The means may be likened to a seed, the end to a tree.'
  • Gandhi: 'Real home-rule is self-rule or self-control.'
  • Gandhi: 'Performance of duty and observance of morality are convertible terms.'
  • Gandhi: passive resistance secures rights by personal suffering, and the resister accepts the penalty.
  • Ambedkar, 4 November 1948: 'Constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated.'
  • Ambedkar, 25 November 1949: three cautions: constitutional methods, no hero-worship in politics, social democracy.
  • Ambedkar: liberty, equality and fraternity cannot be divorced from one another.

How the exam uses it

Questions often give a line from Gandhi or Ambedkar and ask what it means today. Knowing the sentence, the text it comes from and the argument around it lets the answer explain and apply. Present the two thinkers accurately where they differ, as on methods of protest, and give each one's reasons. Do not attribute to either a saying you have not seen in a text.

Test yourself (no peeking)

Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.

  1. What does Gandhi mean by comparing means to a seed and the end to a tree?
  2. How does Hind Swaraj define real home-rule?
  3. What two features mark passive resistance as Gandhi describes it?
  4. What did Ambedkar mean by constitutional morality, and why did he say it has to be cultivated?
  5. State Ambedkar's three cautions of 25 November 1949.
Today 40 days 3 days10 daysa month With Aspiran Read once
How memory usually fades, and what bringing it back at the right time does. The app keeps that timetable for you.

Sources: M. K. Gandhi, Indian Home Rule (Hind Swaraj), chapters XIII, XVI, XVII and Conclusion (Project Gutenberg eBook 40461); Constituent Assembly Debates, 4 November 1948 and 25 November 1949, speeches of Dr B. R. Ambedkar (transcription at constitutionofindia.net)

Syllabus topic: Moral thinkers of India and the world (with the PYQs on it)

More notes

All notes →