Notes · GS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
Fiscal federalism: who taxes, who spends, and how the money is shared
By the end, you will be able to explain the gap between what States earn and what they spend, trace each route by which Union money reaches them, and weigh the main disputes, from cesses to GST.
9
PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 9
The vertical gap
The Constitution gives the Union the taxes with the widest base and the most buoyancy: income tax other than on agricultural income, corporation tax, customs and, before GST, most excise duties. It gives the States most of the work that touches people directly: police, public health, agriculture, much of education and local roads. The result is a vertical imbalance. States together account for well over half of general government spending but raise a much smaller share of revenue on their own.
The Constitution's answer is to share. The question is never whether the Union should transfer money, but how much, by what formula, and with how much freedom for the State to spend it. There is also a horizontal imbalance: some States are far richer than others, so a formula that only returned taxes to where they were collected would widen the gap between them. Every transfer route below is a mix of these two aims, closing the vertical gap and evening out the horizontal one.
Tax devolution through the Finance Commission
The largest and least conditional route is the States' share in Union taxes. Article 270, as amended by the Eightieth Amendment of 2000, makes all Union taxes and duties shareable, forming a 'divisible pool', except cesses and surcharges and a few taxes assigned elsewhere. The Finance Commission, appointed by the President under Article 280 every five years or earlier, recommends two things: the share of the pool that goes to the States as a whole, which is the vertical share, and the formula by which that share is divided among them, which is the horizontal share.
The Fifteenth Finance Commission set the States' share at forty-one per cent for 2021 to 2026, down from forty-two because Jammu and Kashmir had become a Union territory. Its formula gave the largest weight, forty-five per cent, to income distance, meaning how far a State's income per head lies below the richest State's, with the rest to population, area, forest and ecology, demographic performance and tax effort. The Sixteenth Finance Commission, chaired by Arvind Panagariya, submitted its report on 17 November 2025 and kept the States' share at forty-one per cent for 2026 to 2031. Its new formula gives per capita GSDP distance 42.5 per cent, population (2011) 17.5, and demographic performance, area, forest and a new criterion, a State's contribution to GDP, 10 each; tax effort was dropped. The government accepted both the share and the formula in February 2026. Devolved money is untied: the State decides how to spend it.
Grants: statutory, discretionary and scheme-based
The second route is grants. Under Article 275, Parliament provides grants-in-aid from the Consolidated Fund to States in need of assistance, on the Finance Commission's recommendation. These include revenue deficit grants to States whose revenue falls short of their needs even after devolution, grants for local bodies, and grants for disaster management. They are called statutory grants.
Under Article 282, the Union may make grants for any public purpose, even outside its own legislative field. This article carries most of the money for centrally sponsored schemes, such as those for rural employment, housing, health and school education, in which the Union pays a share and the State the rest, usually in a ratio of sixty to forty, or ninety to ten for the north-eastern and Himalayan States. These transfers come with conditions and design set in New Delhi. States argue that a growing share of transfers through schemes rather than devolution narrows their freedom to set their own priorities.
Cesses, surcharges and borrowing
Cesses and surcharges are the sharpest point of dispute. Because Article 270 keeps them outside the divisible pool and Article 271 lets the Union levy surcharges for its own purposes, money raised in this form is not shared with the States. Their share in the Union's gross tax revenue rose markedly in the decade to the early 2020s. States argue that this lets the Union raise revenue while lowering the base on which their forty-one per cent is calculated; the Union replies that cesses fund specific purposes, such as roads, health and education, much of which reaches States in other forms.
Borrowing is the other lever. Under Article 293, a State that owes money to the Union, as every State does, needs the Union's consent to borrow. The Union sets each State's net borrowing ceiling, usually around three per cent of its gross state domestic product, and has at times allowed more if a State carried out reforms, for instance in the power sector. Since 2020-21 the Union has also given States interest-free fifty-year loans for capital investment.
GST and pooled sovereignty
The Goods and Services Tax, introduced on 1 July 2017 by the One Hundred and First Amendment, changed fiscal federalism more than anything since 1950. Article 246A gives both Parliament and State legislatures the power to tax the supply of goods and services, and Article 279A creates the GST Council, chaired by the Union Finance Minister with State finance ministers as members. Decisions need three-fourths of the weighted votes, with the Union holding one-third and the States together two-thirds, so neither side can carry a decision alone. In Union of India v Mohit Minerals (2022), the Supreme Court held that the Council's recommendations are persuasive, not binding, on Parliament and the States.
States gave up their power to set rates on most goods in return for a promise of compensation for five years, at an assumed revenue growth of fourteen per cent a year. Compensation ended in June 2022, but the cess that funded it was continued to repay loans taken during the pandemic. From 22 September 2025 the GST Council kept it only on tobacco products and pan masala, until those loans are fully repaid. The rate structure was simplified to two main rates of five and eighteen per cent, with a forty per cent rate for a few goods, from 22 September 2025. The lasting question is whether pooling of tax powers has made States partners or dependants.
Key facts
- Article 270 (after the 80th Amendment, 2000): all Union taxes shareable except cesses and surcharges.
- Article 280: Finance Commission every five years; recommends vertical and horizontal shares.
- Fifteenth FC: 41 per cent; income distance weight 45 per cent. Sixteenth FC (Panagariya): 41 per cent for 2026-31; GSDP distance 42.5, population 17.5, contribution to GDP 10; accepted.
- Article 275: statutory grants on FC advice; Article 282: discretionary grants, used for centrally sponsored schemes.
- Article 293: a State indebted to the Union needs its consent to borrow.
- GST Council: three-fourths of weighted votes; Union one-third, States two-thirds.
- Mohit Minerals (2022): GST Council recommendations not binding.
- GST rates from 22 September 2025: 5, 18 and 40 per cent.
How the exam uses it
Prelims tests Articles and numbers: which Article covers grants for any public purpose, what share the Finance Commission gives, how GST Council votes are weighted. Mains asks whether Indian fiscal federalism is cooperative or centralising; an answer should cover devolution, the shift to scheme grants, cesses and surcharges, borrowing limits and the GST Council, and give both sides. Past papers: Mains 2025 GS Paper II Q14 asked how recent reforms have affected fiscal federalism; Prelims 2023 Q29 asked which criteria the Fifteenth Finance Commission used. The usual mistake now is to mix up the two Commissions: the Sixteenth dropped tax effort and added contribution to GDP.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- Distinguish the vertical and the horizontal imbalance.
- Why do States object to the rise of cesses and surcharges?
- Under which Article do centrally sponsored schemes mostly run?
- Can the Union pass a GST Council decision without any State's support? Explain with the vote shares.
- What did the Supreme Court hold in Mohit Minerals?
Sources: The Constitution of India (as on 1 May 2024), Legislative Department, https://cdnbbsr.s3waas.gov.in/s380537a945c7aaa788ccfcdf1b99b5d8f/uploads/2024/07/20240716890312078.pdf, opened 2026-11-21; Budget 2026-27, Speech of the Minister of Finance, 1 February 2026, https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/doc/budget_speech.pdf, opened 2026-11-20; Report of the Sixteenth Finance Commission, Volume I, https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/doc/16fcvol1.pdf, opened 2026-11-20; Explanatory Memorandum on Action Taken on the Sixteenth Finance Commission recommendations, Ministry of Finance, February 2026, https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/doc/16fc.pdf, opened 2026-11-20; PIB, Fifteenth Finance Commission report for 2021-26 laid in Parliament, 1 February 2021, https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1693868, opened 2026-11-20; PIB, Recommendations of the 56th GST Council meeting, 3 September 2025, https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2163555, opened 2026-11-20; UPSC question paper csm-2025-gs2, https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/GENERAL-STUDIES-PAPER-II-QP-CSM-25-010925.pdf, opened 2026-10-24; UPSC question paper csp-2023-gs1 with official answer key https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/AnsKey-CSP-2023-Paper-I-090524.pdf, https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/QP_CS_Pre_Exam_2023_280523.pdf, opened 2026-11-03
Syllabus topic: Government budgeting and taxation (with the PYQs on it)
More notes
- Measuring growth: GDP, GVA and national incomeGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Inflation and monetary policy: how India measures prices and how the RBI targets themGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Banking in India: structure, bad loans and inclusionGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Government budgeting and taxation: the Budget, deficits, FRBM and GSTGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Agriculture: MSP, procurement, the PDS and farm supportGS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security
- Industry, liberalisation and infrastructure since 1991GS3: Economy, Environment, Science, Security