Notes · GS2: Polity, Governance, IR
Cooperative federalism: institutions and the debate
By the end, you will know how the Constitution divides power, which bodies help the Centre and states cooperate, where NITI Aayog and the GST Council fit, and the debates.
What cooperative federalism means
In a federation, power is divided between a central government and regional governments, each with its own sphere. Cooperative federalism is the idea that these levels should work together on shared problems rather than act in isolation or compete for control.
Article 1 of the Constitution describes India as a 'Union of States'. The word 'federation' does not appear. B. R. Ambedkar explained in the Constituent Assembly that the Union is indestructible and states have no right to secede.
Scholars have described the Indian system in different ways. Some call it 'quasi-federal', because the Centre has strong powers: residuary powers, the power to create or alter states under Article 3, and emergency provisions. Others stress that states have real powers of their own, and that the Supreme Court has held federalism to be part of the basic structure of the Constitution, notably in S. R. Bommai (1994).
Cooperative federalism sits between these views. It accepts a strong Centre, but holds that national goals are best met when the Centre and states consult and act together. A related idea, 'competitive federalism', encourages states to compete with one another on governance and investment.
The Seventh Schedule: who does what
Article 246 divides legislative power through three lists in the Seventh Schedule.
The Union List covers subjects of national importance, such as defence, foreign affairs, currency, railways and atomic energy. At the start, it had 97 entries. The State List covers matters such as police, public order, public health and agriculture, and originally had 66 entries. The Concurrent List, on which both Parliament and state legislatures can make laws, includes subjects such as criminal law, marriage, forests and education, and originally had 47 entries.
The 42nd Amendment Act, 1976 moved five subjects from the State List to the Concurrent List: education, forests, weights and measures, protection of wild animals and birds, and administration of justice.
Residuary powers, over subjects in none of the lists, lie with Parliament under Article 248. If a state law on a concurrent subject conflicts with a central law, the central law generally prevails under Article 254, unless the state law has received the President's assent.
Parliament can also legislate on state subjects in some situations: when the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution under Article 249, during an emergency, when two or more states request it, or to implement treaties.
Forums for working together
The Constitution and Parliament have created forums where the Centre and states can meet.
Article 263 allows the President to set up an Inter-State Council to inquire into disputes between states, investigate subjects of common interest, and recommend better coordination of policy. It was set up in 1990, following the recommendation of the Sarkaria Commission, which had been appointed in 1983 to review Centre-state relations. The Council is chaired by the Prime Minister. Its members include the Chief Ministers of all states and of Union Territories with legislatures, administrators of other Union Territories, and six Union Cabinet Ministers nominated by the Prime Minister.
Zonal Councils were created under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. There are five, each chaired by the Union Home Minister, and they discuss common issues of the states in a zone. The North Eastern Council was set up separately under its own Act.
The Finance Commission, under Article 280, recommends how central taxes are shared between the Centre and states, and among states. It is a constitutional body appointed every five years.
Critics note that the Inter-State Council has met only rarely, which limits its role in practice.
From Planning Commission to NITI Aayog
The Planning Commission was set up in March 1950 by a resolution of the Union Cabinet. It was neither constitutional nor statutory. It drew up the Five-Year Plans and played a major role in allocating plan funds to states. The National Development Council, which included the Chief Ministers, approved the Plans.
Supporters saw the Commission as a tool of coordinated national planning. Critics saw it as a top-down body that reduced states to supplicants for funds, and argued that a single plan model did not suit India's diversity.
On 1 January 2015, the government replaced it with the National Institution for Transforming India, or NITI Aayog, also through a Cabinet resolution. NITI Aayog is a policy think tank. It does not allocate funds to states; that role has shifted mainly to the Finance Commission and the ministries.
NITI Aayog's Governing Council includes the Prime Minister, the Chief Ministers of all states and of Union Territories with legislatures, and the Lieutenant Governors of other Union Territories. It describes its approach as promoting cooperative and competitive federalism, for example through rankings of states on health, education and other indicators.
The GST Council: shared tax, shared forum
The Goods and Services Tax brought together many central and state indirect taxes into one system. It needed a constitutional change, because the Centre and states had separate taxing powers.
The 101st Amendment Act, 2016 added Article 246A, which gives both Parliament and state legislatures the power to make laws on GST. It also added Article 279A, which created the GST Council. GST came into force on 1 July 2017.
The Council is chaired by the Union Finance Minister. Its members include the Union Minister of State in charge of revenue or finance and the finance or taxation ministers of all states. Decisions need a majority of not less than three-fourths of the weighted votes of members present and voting. The Centre's vote carries one-third of the weight, and the states together carry two-thirds. So neither side can push a decision through alone.
Many see the Council as a working model of cooperative federalism, since it has made a large number of decisions through discussion. In Mohit Minerals (2022), the Supreme Court held that its recommendations are persuasive, not binding, and that Parliament and the states both retain the power to legislate on GST.
Both sides of the debate
Is Indian federalism becoming more cooperative or more centralised? Informed people disagree.
Those who see a cooperative trend point to the GST Council, the Governing Council of NITI Aayog, a larger share of central taxes devolved to states on the Fourteenth Finance Commission's recommendation, and joint efforts in crises such as the pandemic. They argue that national problems, from disease control to infrastructure, need close coordination.
Those who see centralisation point to centrally sponsored schemes that come with conditions, the growth of cesses and surcharges that are not shared with states, delays in GST compensation, and disputes over the role of Governors. They also cite past misuse of Article 356, which the Supreme Court sought to limit in S. R. Bommai (1994), and the rare meetings of the Inter-State Council.
Commissions have offered remedies. The Sarkaria Commission and the Punchhi Commission, set up in 2007, recommended more consultation, a more active Inter-State Council and safeguards on the use of Article 356.
For Mains, present both trends with examples, avoid party framing, and suggest institutional improvements, such as regular Inter-State Council meetings.
Key facts
- Article 1 describes India as a 'Union of States'.
- Article 246 and the Seventh Schedule divide legislative power into three lists.
- The 42nd Amendment, 1976 moved five subjects, including education, to the Concurrent List.
- Residuary powers lie with Parliament under Article 248.
- The Inter-State Council under Article 263 was set up in 1990 on Sarkaria's recommendation.
- NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015.
- The 101st Amendment, 2016 added Article 279A, creating the GST Council.
- In the GST Council, the Centre has one-third of the weighted votes.
How the exam uses it
Prelims asks about articles, list subjects, composition of the Inter-State Council and GST Council, and voting rules. Mains asks you to critically examine whether Indian federalism is becoming cooperative or centralised, or to compare NITI Aayog with the Planning Commission.
Both sides
Some argue that institutions like the GST Council and NITI Aayog, and higher tax devolution, show federalism becoming more cooperative. Others argue that conditional schemes, unshared cesses, Governors' roles and a rarely convened Inter-State Council show centralisation. Both sides agree that stronger, regular forums for consultation would help.
Test yourself (no peeking)
Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.
- Why do some scholars call the Indian system 'quasi-federal'?
- Which five subjects did the 42nd Amendment move to the Concurrent List?
- Who chairs the Inter-State Council, and which commission recommended setting it up?
- How does NITI Aayog's role differ from that of the Planning Commission?
- How are votes weighted in the GST Council, and why does that matter?
Sources: Constitution of India; NCERT Class XI Indian Constitution at Work; Sarkaria Commission Report
More notes
- Transparency and accountability: RTI, citizen charters, social auditGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- e-Governance: models, applications, limits and user-centred designGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Civil services in a democracy: neutrality, accountability, reformGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Development actors: NGOs, SHGs, pressure groups, civil society, donorsGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Welfare of vulnerable sections: laws, institutions, mechanismsGS2: Polity, Governance, IR
- Issues relating to health: system tiers, financing, key programmesGS2: Polity, Governance, IR