Aspiran

Notes · GS4: Ethics

Aristotle, Kant and Mill in their own words

By the end, you will be able to state the central claim of each of the three thinkers in words taken from their own books, and say what each claim asks of a public servant.

9 min read Updated 2026-11-14

11

PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 11

'16'17'18'19'20'21'22'233'244'254'26

Why read the words themselves

The syllabus of General Studies Paper IV asks for the contributions of moral thinkers and philosophers from India and the world. An earlier note sets out the main schools. This note goes to three books and reads a few sentences from each: Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, Kant's Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysic of Morals, and Mill's Utilitarianism.

There are two reasons for doing this. The first is accuracy. Summaries passed from one guide to another drift, and sayings are attached to thinkers who never wrote them. A sentence checked against the book cannot drift. The second is understanding. A thinker's own sentence usually shows the reason for the view, which a label such as virtue ethics or deontology does not.

The quotations below are from English translations that are in the public domain: Aristotle in the translation of D. P. Chase, and Kant in the translation of T. K. Abbott. Mill wrote in English. Other translations word these passages differently, so an answer should give the idea in its own words and quote only what the candidate remembers exactly. The Hindi renderings in this note are ours and are not from a published Hindi translation.

Aristotle: character is formed by doing

Aristotle's question is what kind of person one should be. His answer starts from an observation about how skills are learned. In Book II he writes: 'men come to be builders, for instance, by building; harp-players, by playing on the harp: exactly so, by doing just actions we come to be just; by doing the actions of self-mastery we come to be perfected in self-mastery; and by doing brave actions brave.'

Virtue, then, is not knowledge of a rule. It is a settled state of character produced by repeated action. A person becomes honest by acting honestly until it is second nature.

He then says what kind of state it is: 'Virtue then is "a state apt to exercise deliberate choice, being in the relative mean, determined by reason, and as the man of practical wisdom would determine."' The mean is the point between too much and too little. Of the feelings he says that to feel them 'when we ought, on what occasions, towards whom, why, and as, we should do, is the mean'. Courage lies between rashness and cowardice. The mean is relative: it is not an arithmetical middle, and it has to be judged in each situation by practical wisdom.

He also takes a long view of a good life. Happiness is activity in accordance with virtue over a whole life, 'for as it is not one swallow or one fine day that makes a spring, so it is not one day or a short time that makes a man blessed and happy.'

For a public servant, three things follow. Integrity is built by daily practice in small matters, long before a large test arrives. Good conduct needs judgement and cannot be reduced to a manual: the right degree of firmness with a crowd is neither harshness nor weakness. And institutions matter, since habits are formed by what an organisation rewards and tolerates.

Kant: the good will and the test of a universal law

Kant's question is what makes an action morally worthy. He opens the first section with the sentence: 'Nothing can possibly be conceived in the world, or even out of it, which can be called good, without qualification, except a good will.' Intelligence, courage and even self-control can serve bad ends, and he gives a hard example: 'the coolness of a villain not only makes him far more dangerous'. Only the will to do what is right because it is right is good in every case.

How does such a will decide? Kant gives a test, which he calls the categorical imperative: 'Act only on that maxim whereby thou canst at the same time will that it should become a universal law.' A maxim is the rule on which one is about to act. His example is a false promise made to escape a difficulty. He finds that 'while I can will the lie, I can by no means will that lying should be a universal law. For with such a law there would be no promises at all'. The maxim defeats itself once everyone follows it.

He gives a second form of the same principle: 'So act as to treat humanity, whether in thine own person or in that of any other, in every case as an end withal, never as means only.' People may be asked to serve our purposes, as a clerk serves an office, but never only so. They have purposes of their own, and they cannot be deceived or coerced as if they were tools.

For a public servant, the first test asks: could I accept this as a rule for every officer in every such case? It rules out the exception made for a relative or for oneself. The second asks: am I treating this citizen, this subordinate, this accused person as someone owed reasons and a hearing? It rules out using a person to make an example, however useful the result. Kant's weakness is also plain: where two duties conflict, as truthfulness and the protection of a life may, the test does not say which gives way.

Mill: the greatest happiness, impartially counted

Mill's question is what makes an action right. His answer is stated in chapter II: 'The creed which accepts as the foundation of morals, Utility, or the Greatest Happiness Principle, holds that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness.'

Two clarifications in the same chapter matter a great deal. First, pleasures differ in kind as well as in amount. 'It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied.' The happiness to be promoted includes the exercise of the higher faculties, not mere contentment.

Second, the happiness that counts is everyone's, counted equally. The standard 'is not the agent's own happiness, but that of all concerned. As between his own happiness and that of others, utilitarianism requires him to be as strictly impartial as a disinterested and benevolent spectator.'

For a public servant this is the reasoning behind much of policy: compare the options by their effects on all who are affected, give no extra weight to oneself or one's own, and choose what does the most good. It supports impartiality and attention to results that can be measured.

Its difficulty is equally well known. A sum of happiness can be raised by imposing a heavy cost on a few, and the principle by itself does not forbid that. Mill takes up the objection in his chapter on justice; a candidate need only know that the objection exists and that rights are the usual answer to it.

Using the three together

The three thinkers ask different questions, and that is why they can be used together. Mill asks about results for everyone. Kant asks whether the rule can be universal and whether persons are respected. Aristotle asks what a person of practical wisdom and good character would do.

In a case study, a course of action that passes all three tests is well supported. Where the tests disagree, the disagreement is the dilemma, and naming it earns credit.

Quote sparingly. One exact sentence, attributed to the right book, is enough in an answer. A paraphrase with the thinker's name is always safe.

Key facts

  • Aristotle: 'by doing just actions we come to be just' (Nicomachean Ethics, Book II, Chase translation).
  • Aristotle: virtue is a state of deliberate choice lying in a mean relative to us, as practical wisdom would determine.
  • Kant: nothing is good without qualification except a good will.
  • Kant: 'Act only on that maxim whereby thou canst at the same time will that it should become a universal law' (Abbott translation).
  • Kant: treat humanity 'in every case as an end withal, never as means only'.
  • Mill: actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness (Utilitarianism, chapter II).
  • Mill: the standard is the happiness of all concerned, judged as by a disinterested and benevolent spectator.

How the exam uses it

Questions on thinkers ask what a view means and how it applies to present conditions or to administration. An answer that gives the central claim accurately, in one sentence, and then applies it to a concrete situation is stronger than one that lists many names. In case studies the three tests of results, universal rule and character give reasons of three kinds for a chosen course.

Test yourself (no peeking)

Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.

  1. How, according to Aristotle, does a person become just?
  2. What does Aristotle mean by the mean, and why is it called relative?
  3. State Kant's test of the universal law and his example of the false promise.
  4. What does it mean to treat a person never as means only?
  5. What two clarifications does Mill add to the Greatest Happiness Principle?
Today 40 days 3 days10 daysa month With Aspiran Read once
How memory usually fades, and what bringing it back at the right time does. The app keeps that timetable for you.

Sources: Aristotle, The Nicomachean Ethics, translated by D. P. Chase (Project Gutenberg eBook 8438), Books I and II; Immanuel Kant, Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysic of Morals, translated by T. K. Abbott (Project Gutenberg eBook 5682), First and Second Sections; John Stuart Mill, Utilitarianism (Project Gutenberg eBook 11224), chapter II; UPSC CSE notification: syllabus of General Studies Paper IV

Syllabus topic: Moral thinkers of India and the world (with the PYQs on it)

More notes

All notes →