Aspiran

Notes · GS2: Polity, Governance, IR

Appointment to constitutional posts: who appoints, how they are protected, and why it matters

By the end, you will be able to set out, for the main constitutional offices, the appointing authority, the tenure, the manner of removal and the bar on later office, and to explain how these features protect independence.

11 min read Updated 2026-11-21

12

PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 12

1'162'171'181'191'20'212'22'231'241'252'26

What a constitutional post is

The syllabus of General Studies Paper II lists appointment to various constitutional posts, and the powers, functions and responsibilities of various constitutional bodies. A constitutional post is an office created by the Constitution itself. A statutory post is created by an Act of Parliament, and can be altered or abolished by another Act. A constitutional post can be changed only by amending the Constitution.

The offices that usually matter for the examination are the Comptroller and Auditor-General of India, the Attorney-General for India and the Advocate-General of a State, the Chief Election Commissioner and the Election Commissioners, the Chairman and members of the Union and State Public Service Commissions, the Finance Commission, and the National Commissions for the Scheduled Castes, the Scheduled Tribes and the Backward Classes.

Most of these offices check the government in some way: they audit its accounts, conduct the elections it contests, select its civil servants, or divide revenue between the Union and the States. The design problem is therefore the same in each case. The office-holder is appointed by the executive, in the name of the President, and yet must be able to act against the executive's wishes. The Constitution deals with this through four devices: a fixed tenure, a difficult removal, service conditions that cannot be worsened, and limits on employment after office.

The Comptroller and Auditor-General and the law officers

Article 148 says that the Comptroller and Auditor-General shall be appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal, and shall only be removed in like manner and on the like grounds as a Judge of the Supreme Court. Neither the salary nor the rights in respect of leave, pension or age of retirement can be varied to the holder's disadvantage after appointment. Under Article 148(4) the Comptroller and Auditor-General is not eligible for further office under the Government of India or of any State after ceasing to hold the office. The term and other conditions are fixed by a law of Parliament.

These provisions together show the pattern at its strongest: removal as difficult as that of a judge, protected conditions, and no later government post to hope for.

The law officers are designed differently, because their task is different. Under Article 76 the President appoints as Attorney-General a person qualified to be appointed a Judge of the Supreme Court. The Attorney-General advises the Government of India on legal matters, has a right of audience in all courts in the territory of India, and holds office during the pleasure of the President. Article 165 makes parallel provision for an Advocate-General in each State, who must be qualified to be a High Court judge and holds office during the pleasure of the Governor.

The Attorney-General is the government's lawyer, not a check on it. Tenure at pleasure is therefore consistent with the office, where it would not be for an auditor.

The Election Commission

Article 324(2) provides that the Election Commission shall consist of the Chief Election Commissioner and such number of other Election Commissioners, if any, as the President may fix, and that their appointment shall, subject to the provisions of any law made in that behalf by Parliament, be made by the President.

Article 324(5) protects the Chief Election Commissioner in two ways: the Chief Election Commissioner shall not be removed except in like manner and on the like grounds as a Judge of the Supreme Court, and the conditions of service shall not be varied to the holder's disadvantage after appointment. Any other Election Commissioner shall not be removed except on the recommendation of the Chief Election Commissioner.

For many years Parliament made no law on the manner of appointment, and appointments were made by the President on the advice of the government. In Anoop Baranwal v Union of India (2023) a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court dealt with this gap. Parliament then enacted the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. Under section 7 of the Act, appointments are made by the President on the recommendation of a Selection Committee consisting of the Prime Minister as Chairperson, the Leader of Opposition in the House of the People, and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. Under section 6, a Search Committee headed by the Minister of Law and Justice prepares a panel of five persons for the Selection Committee.

The Act has been challenged in the Supreme Court. On 23 September 2026 a two-judge bench directed that the petitions be placed before the Chief Justice of India for the constitution of a Constitution Bench to decide the validity of sections 6, 7 and 8. As on 12 November 2026 the validity of the Act is undecided, and an answer should say so.

The debate is about the composition of the committee. One view is that a committee with two members from the government leaves the choice with the executive. The other is that Article 324(2) expressly leaves the matter to Parliament. A candidate should be able to state both and need not decide between them.

Public Service Commissions, the Finance Commission and the National Commissions

Public Service Commissions. Under Article 316 the Chairman and members of the Union Commission are appointed by the President, and those of a State Commission by the Governor. As nearly as may be one-half of the members must have held office for at least ten years under the Government of India or of a State. A member holds office for six years or until the age of sixty-five in the Union Commission, and sixty-two in a State Commission, whichever is earlier.

Removal is by the President, under Article 317, on the ground of misbehaviour, and only after the Supreme Court, on a reference by the President, has held an inquiry and reported that the member ought to be removed. This applies to State Commissions as well: the Governor appoints but cannot remove. Article 319 limits later employment. The Chairman of the Union Commission is ineligible for any further employment under the Government of India or of a State.

The Finance Commission. Under Article 280 the President constitutes a Finance Commission at the expiration of every fifth year, or earlier, consisting of a Chairman and four other members. Parliament may by law determine their qualifications and the manner of their selection. The Commission recommends the distribution of the net proceeds of taxes between the Union and the States and the principles governing grants-in-aid. It is a body constituted afresh each time, not a standing office.

The National Commissions. Article 338 provides for a National Commission for Scheduled Castes consisting of a Chairperson, a Vice-Chairperson and three other Members, appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal. Articles 338A and 338B make like provision for the Scheduled Tribes and the Backward Classes. Their conditions of service and tenure are determined by the President by rule, which gives them less protection than the auditor or the Public Service Commissions enjoy.

Reading the pattern, and the debate

Set side by side, the offices show a scale of protection. At one end stand the Comptroller and Auditor-General and the Chief Election Commissioner, removable only like a Supreme Court judge. Next come the members of Public Service Commissions, removable only after an inquiry by the Supreme Court. Then the other Election Commissioners, protected by the need for the Chief Election Commissioner's recommendation. Then bodies whose tenure is set by rules. At the other end are the law officers, who serve at pleasure.

Three questions recur in the debate on appointments. The first is who selects. Where the Constitution says only that the President shall appoint, the choice is in practice the government's, and proposals have been made over the years for selection committees that include the Opposition or the judiciary. The second is employment after office. A bar on later posts, as for the Comptroller and Auditor-General, removes a possible inducement; where there is no bar, the concern remains. The third is the gap between offices of the same body, as between the Chief Election Commissioner and the other Commissioners.

An answer should describe what the text provides, state the concern, and give the opposing consideration: an elected government is accountable for appointments it makes, and independence after appointment is secured mainly by tenure and removal, which the Constitution has made strong for the offices that matter most.

Key facts

  • Article 148: the CAG is appointed by the President by warrant and removed only like a Supreme Court judge; Article 148(4) bars further government office.
  • Article 76: the Attorney-General must be qualified to be a Supreme Court judge and holds office during the pleasure of the President.
  • Article 324(5): the CEC is removable only like a Supreme Court judge; other Election Commissioners only on the CEC's recommendation.
  • 2023 Act, section 7: Selection Committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.
  • As on 12 November 2026 the validity of the 2023 Act is undecided; on 23 September 2026 it was referred for a Constitution Bench.
  • Article 316: UPSC members serve six years or until sixty-five; State Commission members until sixty-two. Article 317: removal only after a Supreme Court inquiry.
  • Article 280: a Finance Commission of a Chairman and four other members, constituted every fifth year or earlier.

How the exam uses it

Prelims questions test exact provisions: who appoints, who removes, the age limits, and which offices are barred from later employment. Mains questions ask whether the appointment process secures independence. Compare offices on the four devices of tenure, removal, protected conditions and post-office limits, state the present position of the 2023 Act accurately, and give both sides of the debate on selection. A past question to practise with: Mains 2025 GS2 Q5 asks about the role of the Attorney General of India; set out Article 76 (qualification, pleasure tenure, right of audience) before you assess the role. The usual mistake is to give the Attorney-General the same protection as the CAG or the CEC; the Attorney-General holds office during the pleasure of the President, with no fixed term.

Test yourself (no peeking)

Try to answer each one from memory, out loud or on paper. The effort of pulling it out is what makes it stay.

  1. What is the difference between a constitutional post and a statutory post?
  2. Which four devices does the Constitution use to protect an office-holder's independence?
  3. How does the removal of the Chief Election Commissioner differ from that of another Election Commissioner?
  4. Who appoints and who removes a member of a State Public Service Commission?
  5. Why is tenure at pleasure consistent with the office of Attorney-General?
Today 40 days 3 days10 daysa month With Aspiran Read once
How memory usually fades, and what bringing it back at the right time does. The app keeps that timetable for you.

Sources: The Constitution of India, as on 1 May 2024 (Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice), https://cdnbbsr.s3waas.gov.in/s380537a945c7aaa788ccfcdf1b99b5d8f/uploads/2024/07/20240716890312078.pdf, opened 2026-11-20; Supreme Court of India, Dr Jaya Thakur v Union of India, order of 23 September 2026, https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2024/146/146_2024_7_1501_74714_Judgement_23-Sep-2026.pdf, opened 2026-11-20; Verdictum, report of 2 March 2023 on Anoop Baranwal v Union of India (secondary), https://www.verdictum.in/court-updates/supreme-court/committee-of-pm-cji-and-leader-of-opposition-to-appoint-election-commission-members-constitution-bench-1465036, opened 2026-11-20

Syllabus topic: Elections and the Representation of the People Act (with the PYQs on it)

More notes

All notes →