Mains answer writing · GS2
Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.
See this PYQ in the UPSC paper →
What the question wants
Two parts: trace the collegium's evolution, then critically compare India's and the USA's systems.
Where your 250 words go · 15 marks
Intro~30
Evolution: First Judges case (1981) gave the…~45
NJAC: the 99th Amendment (2014) was struck down in…~45
India: protects independence, but criticised for…~45
USA: President nominates, Senate confirms; open…~45
Conclusion~35
How the app marks it (a sample)
Directive
Structure
Content
Examples
Conclusion
Below · At · Above (against a well-scoring UPSC answer)
Introduction
Article 124 requires 'consultation' with judges; courts turned this into the collegium system.
Body: the points to cover
- Evolution: First Judges case (1981) gave the executive primacy; Second (1993) created the collegium; Third (1998) set CJI plus four.
- NJAC: the 99th Amendment (2014) was struck down in 2015; the collegium continues.
- India: protects independence, but criticised for opacity and limited diversity.
- USA: President nominates, Senate confirms; open hearings, but appointments can become politicised.
Conclusion
Way forward: keep judicial primacy but add published criteria and reasons.
The mistake most people make
Calling one system clearly better without weighing both sides.
This is a frame, not a model answer: write it in your own words, with your own examples.
More mains answer writing
- Mains 2024 GS2 Q1: Examine the need for electoral reforms as suggested by various…GS2
- Mains 2024 GS2 Q2: Explain and distinguish between Lok Adalats and Arbitration…GS2
- Mains 2024 GS2 Q3: "The growth of cabinet system has practically resulted in the…GS2
- Mains 2024 GS2 Q4: "The duty of the Comptroller and Auditor General is not merely to…GS2
- Mains 2024 GS2 Q5: Analyse the role of local bodies in providing good governance at…GS2
- Mains 2024 GS2 Q6: Public charitable trusts have the potential to make India's…GS2