Aspiran

Both sides, and myth or fact · 1:48

Two Sides: GM Mustard

Sound is off until you turn it on. Captions are on.

Quick question 1

What did both Supreme Court judges agree the Centre should do in July 2024?

Quick question 2

In a Mains answer on a contested topic like this, what is the sound approach?

▶ All the shorts

Read it instead the full narration

Should India grow genetically modified mustard? Meher and Arun, two made up friends, will argue it on a wall beside a mustard field. The mustard takes no side. India imports more than half of its edible oil. A mustard that yields more could cut that bill. This one also carries a herbicide tolerance trait, and petitioners say India has no guidelines to test for it. The approval is conditional. Experts decided it, and it can be revoked if harm shows up. One judge found the process rushed: a professor's warning about honeybees was overlooked. Its developers report yields about a quarter higher than traditional varieties. More oil from the same field. Farmers could come to depend on a few companies for seed. Long term health effects, and effects on non GM fields, are open questions. What the courts have said. In October 2022, the regulator, GEAC, gave a conditional approval. In July 2024, two Supreme Court judges split on it: one quashed it, one upheld it. Both asked for a national policy on GM crops, made with states and farmers. A larger bench is to decide, and by November 2026 no final ruling has been reported. For GS3 and the essay: both sides, fairly. Then a balanced way forward. The tea has gone cold. The mustard is still yellow, and the question is still open.

45

PYQs on this, 2016 to 2026
Mains, this syllabus line: 45

4'164'175'184'194'204'214'224'234'243'255'26

Watch next